I recently came across a doozy of a sign on the web that said “If I wanted to work for free I’d choose to be a volunteer, not a freelancer. Learn the difference already.” * It inspired the sign that adorns this opinion piece of mine.
Freelancers like me expect to work for pay. We also have our own set rates. If you do not wish to pay anyone for their work, in, say, proofreading a book, find a few volunteer “beta” readers. Don’t bother me with questions if I can either A. work for free or B. work for less than my requested rate. I have bills to pay.
If I want to volunteer at something, I’d go back to volunteering for the Minnesota Transportation Museum at the Minnehaha Depot at Minnehaha Park in Minneapolis, Minnesota. But volunteering, while it may be good for the resume, is not good for the bank account. ‘Nuff said.
I received the following e-mail yesterday concerning Writer.ly, a job site where freelancers could bid on book editing and related projects posted by authors seeking freelance help:
A Writer.ly Farewell
Three years ago, two passionate writers got together based on a common idea: to help writers find the freelancers they needed to get their work polished and published. Their idea turned into a website called Writer.ly, a site that became a wonderful resource to many. In the process, these two passionate writers went on an incredible ride. They learned the ins-and-outs of running a start-up, met many wonderfully talented writers, editors, designers and other publishing professionals, found 15 minutes of fame with Guy Kawasaki, Shawn Welch, Peg Fitzpatrick, Hugh Howey, and many other indie publishing rockstars, convinced an incredible group of equally passionate investors to join our parade, and found others willing to work hard despite our ability to provide a paycheck.
Like many start-ups based on a passion, the reality of finding a sustainable business model proved elusive and the day has come for the Writer.ly marketplace to shut it’s doors. We are sad to disappoint you, the freelancers and writers who made Writer.ly possible and helped us fulfill the dream of being a wonderful resource, but the future of indie publishing is bright and there are now many resources to help you through the sometimes overwhelming process of self-publishing a book.
We will keep Writer.ly’s marketplace available for the completion of any ongoing projects until April 26th and will then go offline. You will continue to be able to access PubChat at it’s new home: indiepubchat.com and can still find us on Twitter @writerlytweets.
Thank you for all your support for the past three years. Wishing you all great success in your publishing endeavors and hope you “Publish Happy.”
The e-mail was signed by Writer.ly’s C.E.O., Abigail Carter. Today her message greets visitors to the site.
The loss of Writer.ly will affect only the handful of freelancers who were able to find consistent work via the site. I and many other freelancers found getting work via Writer.ly to be quite arduous. For one thing, the competition was stiff, as the following exchange I once had with a job poster eloquently illustrates:
I recently bid on your short story collection job. I normally do free sample edits for prospective clients so they can see how I work. Would you be interested in a free sample edit from me? If so, please send me a three page excerpt from your manuscript. Thank you.
Hello – Thanks a ton for your bid. I have received 11 bids on this job and I need some time to make my decision. Cheers, Archana
Eleven bids! This ensured mine was swamped by sheer numbers by default, no matter how carefully worded it was and how reasonable a price I offered.
The biggest stumbling block at Writer.ly was not the competition, however. They are people who posted what I call “dead wood” job postings — that is, authors who joined Writer.ly, posted a job listing, and then proceeded to suffer “sticker shock” once the bids came in. I was frustrated to no end by such people. I now believe that “dead wood” job posters doomed the site, for how could Writer.ly have earned consistent fees from job advertisements if the bulk of them had no bids accepted on them?
In the end, I won eight jobs via Writer.ly’s job listings plus a handful of others via their “Offers” section where freelancers could make their own offers to prospective clients.
One good thing I can say about Writer.ly is that, unlike Elance, which took a bite out of your bid, Writer.ly added their fee on top of yours. This meant I got paid in full.
And so the curtain has fallen across a unique website for authors and freelancers. I wish Writer.ly’s creators all the best in their future endeavors.
A website calling itself MyWritingJob.com was making posts all over the “writing gigs” sections of Minneapolis Craigslist and other Craigslist city sites earlier this year. They contained no e-mail addresses, only this link:
It was a scam that runs a fancy video by you extolling how much money you will make as a freelance writer. When you read the FAQ at the link above, you discover you have to pay to access the site! According to this FAQ:
“Why do I have to pay?
MyWritingJob.com has to charge to keep our extensive list of jobs updated. Our partners don’t pay us (it would be a conflict of interest), so we charge to make sure our jobs are being updated up to 5x per day!”
This spiel sounds too good to be true, folks.
If you click on their FAQ/Support desk link, we find a slightly different reason payment is required:
“Why do I have to pay for a membership?
We are charging you for our services so we can always provide you with the best customer support as well as a constantly updated database of current job listings. If there is an opportunity out there, we will know about it and our members will be the first to have access to it. Running such a large resource takes time and money.”
Okay, now this sounds like pure bullshit here, people.
What was the membership price? $68 U.S. Though this week they claim they have a “special” of $34 U.S. What was this, a site for writing gigs or a health club?
The word “scam” seems to fit here, people.
Ashley Haynes posted to Hub Pages an article that provided the nitty-gritty about the MyWritingJob.com scam. It is at: